The Hickensian
19.05.05 Getting Hicks done
I’ve finally found the tool I want to use as my collection bucket, and like the geek I am, I feel the need to tell you about it.
Like a lot of people, I’ve been sucked in to the whole Getting Things Done cult, and all cult members need a ‘collection bucket’. The bucket is a place to put ‘open loops’ (all those tasks that are rolling around in your head, bothering the hell of you at times when you can do nothing about it), and into a place where they can be listed, reviewed regularly and actioned. For some this tool is a Hipster PDA, for others it could a PIM application like Entourage.
My dilemma was this – I love the organic ‘analog’ feeling of pencil on notebook, but prefer the ease of editing and reordering that a ‘digital’ application would give me.
Here are some of the solutions I’ve tried:
- Backpack
- Moleskine notebooks
- OmniOutliner
- GTDTiddlyWiki
- Sidenote (if this was easy to sync, it’d be fantastic, and I still use this for all my notes/reference)
- xPad
- VoodooPad
- Hipster PDA
Everyone has to find the one that works best for them. You have to feel comfortable with it, but that doesn’t mean that there is one solution that works for everyone.
So what was the winner? I had the idea of setting up a ‘Getting things done’ project in Basecamp and suddenly everything fell into place.
Here are some of the reasons why:
- Mainly using the to-do list section, I created lists for ‘Work’, ‘Home’ and ‘Long Term Goals’. I can view these lists individually, as well as all together on one page. The milestones section becomes a reminders section, for everything from small projects to remembering to do things like a find a plumber.
- No issues syncing between macs – the information is always there – up to date and correct.
- I really like the to-do list functionality (also used in Tada-lists and Backpack). Tick the checkbox and it drops down beneath, greyed out, but still there. This is great for projects that are ‘waiting’ but you’re not finished with yet. It also allows for lists to be reordered, to show task priorities.
- By creating a distant milestone (which I call ‘Marker’), I can attach all my to-do lists to this, and have them show up in iCal’s to-do lists.
- An ‘in the browser’ solution – I’m really keen on the idea of having as few apps around as possible, and doing as much as possible within a tabbed browser.
- All my notes go into the ‘messages’ area, with categories such as ‘code snippets’.
- I’ve already got a Basecamp account. There wasn’t a need to buy a Backpack account, as I didn’t need its unique features, such as sharing pages, or emailing information to a page. Backpack did come very close to being the one, but Basecamp won out.
The result of this organisation is that I now have a bucket that I can access from anywhere with a internet connection (and yes, I’m rarely without one!), When I do need a copy on my mac, I just save a pdf, but usually I’m connected, and just have my ‘bucket’ open in a tab. It works for me, and its helped me feel more relaxed about my workload.
I’d be interested to hear what ‘devices’ you use. What’s worked for you?
Recent Posts
26.01.10 The Handbag has been raised!
22.01.10 Guide to the Internet (2000)
20.01.10 Designer, not a construction worker
19.01.10 Why you can never work 'full time'
16.01.10 Dream Report: Look at the Hygiene!
Or Full Archives
The Hickensian is the journal of Hicksdesign, a creative partnership of Jon & Leigh Hicks. Read more about us.
playlist
Hickr | RSS
Contact
Hicksdesign
Island House
Lower High Street
Burford
Oxfordshire, UK
OX18 4RR
+44 (0)7917 391 536
I am currently working full-time with Opera, and not taking on any new projects
67 comments
Journal RSS Feed





Download vCard
Comments | RSS
∞ Jason Santa Maria said 1727 days ago:
I do the same thing, but I use Ta-Da lists for mine. I know it’s silly, but it’s less intensive than Basecamp and really fast for this particular purpose. My Ta-Da lists are set as my homepage, it always right there under my nose when I need it.∞ Rob Weychert said 1727 days ago:
I actually just use the To-Do lists in iCal. I can categorize and prioritize everything I need to do right there, and it integrates with all of my other Apple apps. Perhaps someday I’ll need something more robust, but for now, it works quite well.∞ Siobhan Curran said 1727 days ago:
Call it “old school” if you like, but I have to put in a plug here for Paper And PencilA wall, covered in Postits, with no way of hiding them by hitting F12 – it’s the 21st Century retro-way to nag yourself to get Stuff™ done.
Isn’t ordering things in an app just another form of procrastination?
∞ Wilson Miner said 1727 days ago:
The killer feature that’s kept me from using Tadalists or Basecamp for GTD is not being able to move items from one list to another. That’s the one thing that keeps me in a desktop app.∞ Vincent Grouls said 1727 days ago:
I use iCal as well. Just the To-Do for my various calendars (Home, Work, Open Source) with some quick notes and reminders if needed.I wish iCal could handle text file attachments for To Do items though; I always write any notes in BBEdit. This has the advantage that I can send these files to friends or colleagues without having to open iCal all the time.
∞ matt Carey said 1727 days ago:
I have always been a Moleskine fan, but have recently made the leap to basecamp.My basecamp use started with just projects for clients, but now I have ones for ‘admin’, ‘project general’, ‘marketing/potential clients’ etc.
I still need the reassurance of my Moleskine, at least for now…
∞ Jan Brasna said 1727 days ago:
Well, I’m also a bit oldskool (eh, ok, frankly… a bit messy) so everything is on papers, only sometimes in thunderbird flags and nokia calendar ;)I’m trying to move forward to some kind of combination of isync, syncml, mailclient, projectmgmt, but it seems rather unreal, so I’ll have to stick more with my basecamp account.
∞ Jason Fried said 1727 days ago:
The killer feature that’s kept me from using Tadalists or Basecamp for GTD is not being able to move items from one list to another. That’s the one thing that keeps me in a desktop app.We’ll be adding this to Backpack shortly. Stay tuned.
∞ Jason Fried said 1727 days ago:
Oh, and we’ve also recently started work on Basecamp 2. Lots of cool stuff headed your way:Read about Basecamp 2
∞ Jason Fried said 1727 days ago:
Ugh, sorry, URL didn’t takehttp://everything.basecamphq.com/archives/000370.php
∞ Dave said 1727 days ago:
Thanks for the list of solutions – I am going to work my way through and see which is the best for me.I see you have gone for an internet app; I usually prefer something on my own server because I feel I have more control (and so I can hack it to pieces). Got to check Basecamp out sometime as well.
∞ Darren said 1727 days ago:
Check out sproutliner. It addresses the biggest issue that I have with ta-da lists etc. by allowing a hierarchy of tasks.Ironically, this web application has one of the best user interfaces of any outliner that I’ve used on Windows, including desktop applications.
There’s no real security in the beta (other than obscurity) but apparently that’s coming as well.
∞ Darren said 1727 days ago:
Hmm, looks like anchor tags are broken. Here’s the site:http://sproutliner.com
∞ Craig C. said 1727 days ago:
I use paper, and I actually find that the act of writing things down is even more helpful than consulting the list. As I’m writing it, I organize and prioritize in my head, and somehow the ritual of scratching words on bark keeps the tasks/items in memory longer. Hence I tend to rewrite my whole list every time I update or reprioritize. Every other page of my inventor-style notebook is an updated list, usually with several items repeated from the previous page.∞ Craig C. said 1727 days ago:
Oh, and the “GETAGRAVATAR” thingie is messing with my transparency! Gonna have to make an opaque one now…∞ Josh Rothman said 1727 days ago:
I use a combination of index cards (in my wallet) and Backpack for now. The most productive I’ve ever been was with a Palm—but eventually I got fed up with the lack of Mac integration. Hopefully someday there’ll be a PDA I can use every day again.∞ clint said 1727 days ago:
its all about tha camp.∞ Greg said 1726 days ago:
You should check out Tasks∞ Greg said 1726 days ago:
Since my A tag didn’t seem to take, here is the URL:http://kingdesign.net/tasks/
∞ Maurice Kühlborn said 1726 days ago:
With Panther I used to have a simple text file which I displayed right on my desktop using geektool. With geektool you have your todo-List always right in your face. The txt-file lives in my dock so I can easily access it to apply changes or additions. Unfortunately there’s no geektool version for Tiger yet.∞ Conánn said 1726 days ago:
Being an incessant scribbler I have little choice other then to use a stack of trusty black Dalar lineless notebooks, I keep trying to find a digital solution but I am much more visual then literate and need to be able to sketch out an idea on the spot.I would like a more attractive alternative to these notebooks but often if they are too precious there is a pressure on the sketch to be worthy.
∞ Jonas Persson said 1726 days ago:
I’m using ThoughtManager on my Palm Tungsten, which also has a desktop version. Unfortunatly I think that’s Windows only – but it works well.∞ Rob Winters said 1726 days ago:
I’m using backback at the moment for organising personal projects and I’m thinking of using it for admin stuff like storing passwords, serial numbers ect but not sure how secure it is. Fantastic app though.∞ Matt said 1726 days ago:
Being a huge GFD fan myself, and being almost on the brink of actually working out how to get things done, I would love to hear more on how you have applied the principles of GFD to running a design shop and a life. I have recently gone it alone as a mercenary software developer and have found balancing life, software development, sales, marketing, admin, taxes, eating etc a big shock. Any more tips and anecdotes you have on this subject would be very appreciated.∞ Jason Gennaro said 1726 days ago:
I’ve been following GTD for a while. As someone with two jobs (gov’t worker/Web developer) and a long commute, I find the only way to keep track of things is to use a PDA. My Palm Tungsten W is souped up with Shadow Plan (http://www.codejedi.com/shadowplan/screenshots.html).The program is an amazing task manager. You can:
-Create hierarchical lists (to any depth)
-Assign start and finish dates and target dates
-Add any number of context tags (e.g., @waiting, @computer)
-Add priority #s
-Add percent of project/task done
-Add a creation date
-Add notes
-Filter your entries by anyone of the above or by other rules
-Link to the Palm Calendar (so you are always on top of your 43 folders)
-Export to Memos or to a Doc file
Shadow Plan also comes with a desktop component for PC or Mac. Really indispensible for my peace of mind.
∞ Taylor McKnight said 1726 days ago:
Maybe you should mention somewhere that anchor tags are stripped :)∞ Donnie Jeter said 1726 days ago:
For me, it’s a combination of ta-da and the moleskine. I also throw a couple of index cards in the back pocket of the notebook just in case. Another hack that has really helped me out is the implementation of tabs in the moleskine. The ability to easily flip to any category is really helpful. I am without an internet connection roughly 30% of the day, during that time the moleskine has really helped me out.∞ Michele said 1726 days ago:
I use both OmniOutliner and Basecamp: a powerful and flexible solution, I think. And I’m wondering what Basecamp2 will bring us…I have to say I’m pretty intrigued by Jason Santa Maria’s solution: TaDa lists as the homepage…got to try this one!
∞ Jon Hicks said 1726 days ago:
Siobhan – nope, its about clearing the head of all those nagging tasks, and giving them somewhere else to live. Then your head is clearer so that you can actually deal with those tasks. Its the same as writing on paper/post-it notes – just a different medium.Darren – thanks for Sproutliner, I hadn’t come across that. It does funny things to Safari, but I’ll try in Firefox
Matt – sure, there’s always going to be the need for something that doesn’t need a power supply!
Greg – Tasks Pro was one of the solutions I tried, and it just didn’t click with me.
∞ John Kopanas said 1726 days ago:
I use cue cards. Nothing beats the feeling of ripping up a cue card once I am finished my task. Plus, I can take them rollerbladding, hiking and even skiing with me. :-)∞ Joachim Bondo said 1726 days ago:
I have to bring your attention to NoteBook by Circus Ponies! An application that not only makes Mac OS X shine (even more), but addresses all the issues you mention for choosing Basecamp.However, NoteBook is an application – not a web solution.
NoteBook does offer to export your notebooks as HTML. I often print out pages if I need to work away from the computer. The printouts look as astonishing as on the screen with the different types of paper, tabs, spiral and punch holes. I really like the realistic look of the notebooks. It offers tons of features in a very elegant user-interface. I’m amazed to see how much effort and attention to detail that has gone into designing this application. And yes, it indexes your pages via Spotlight.
I’m not affiliated with CircusPonies in any way – I just really love this application!
∞ Joachim Bondo said 1726 days ago:
Hmm… your live preview doesn’t match the final result. My links and other markup dissapeared. The link to Circus Ponies is http://www.circusponies.com.∞ tom said 1725 days ago:
Sidenote is some good stuff.Thanks Jon for some good list of apps. I was looking for some stuff like those to manage stuff. :D
∞ Andrew Escobar said 1725 days ago:
Wow –I’m speechless. Well not really…When I looked at the Side Notes, I had to pause and make sure I was looking at it right. My blog ( AndrewEscobar.com ) is not only on Hick’s Side Notes but one of John’s favorit solutions! Thanks you John fro the publicity. I just checked and the link is sending allot of people to the Mail Stamps info page. If you don’t like Mail’s new icons, give it a go.
As for what I use to get things done, I use Backpack now because of the iCal feeds it generates. I use the ‘Hipster PDA’ when I’m on the go and then plug the things I jotted down into iCal or Backpack.
∞ Peter Asquith said 1725 days ago:
I’ve recently become a Basecamp convert too but also use Ta-da Lists for items I’m just doodling around with – the more ephemeral stuff. Oh, and I keep a Moleskine handy to record interesting stuff that I happen upon – just can’t lose that analogue feeling!∞ dotjay said 1725 days ago:
I’m a paper person really, but completely agree about the flexibility given by a digital solution. I blogged a little while back about my Manage-Do flipbook approach, but I’m on the look-out for something more… Maybe I should check out Basecamp in a little more depth.∞ Joen said 1725 days ago:
I use Alex King’s Tasks (The free version). Although I see it’s now called Tasks Jr, the bulk of it is still the same.The beauty part is, it’s web-based, so I can access it anywhere.
∞ John Athayde said 1725 days ago:
I’ve been using the to do lists in iCal for larger things, but I keep reverting to an engineering pad and a black pen. Damn architecture school got me writing in microscopic all caps and I can’t stop.∞ Joshua Peek said 1725 days ago:
I had Ta-Da lists as my home page but ever since Backpack, I just use that.∞ Nathan A Herald said 1725 days ago:
I have just started using Tada lIsts…I want to use Basecamp, but I am waiting until they add the email into basecamp feature…That will be what causes me to pay…
I also use iCal to schedule everything…Bascamp can do this, but I find iCal to be more flexabile with small adjustments…But like I said, after they get Basecamp 2 up and going, I think I will use it solely…
∞ Justin McGonigle said 1725 days ago:
iLearnis easy to use and has a nice interface.
∞ Bob Easton said 1725 days ago:
eMailing things to Backpack gives it the edge that fits my working style. Basecamp had more than I needed, just as you said, and was fine until Backpack came along with the mail-in capability. This was a case of less being more.∞ Nathan Smith said 1724 days ago:
I’m sure it’s been done/mentioned before, but has anyone considered using WordPress and its email-to-blog capability for a To-Do list? One could set up a password protected subdomain running WordPress, and then have an email like ToDo@Example.com which automatically blogs what needs to get done.It would be pretty rudimentary, and I’m sure Basecamp and Backpack offer far more organizational features, but this way it would be hosted on one’s own domain, and you wouldn’t be dependent on a 3rd party app. and possible prices / licensing changes. Anyways, just an idea. I haven’t tried it myself yet.
I’m a big Textpattern fan, but the email-to-blog feature of WP has always seemed intriguing to me.
∞ Jaan Orvet said 1723 days ago:
I find that I can get info in to Backpack quicker than Basecamp.∞ NS said 1722 days ago:
Trumba (in beta but has a lot of potential in the future.) in conjuction with Ta-da lists.∞ Peter Bowyer said 1722 days ago:
I’ve tried Tadalist but usually wanted a description associated with my task, with subtasks nested underneath it…Currently I use a mix of paper (sheets, envelopes, whatever’s to hand – no wonder I lose things!) and OneNote 2003. I love being able to reorder and refine thoughts on the computer, and to be able to organise and not lose them; but often I get thoughts down better on paper – particularly if they’re not too ‘wordy’ ideas I can get them to flow on paper, drawing arrows linking different bits, design doodles etc. I’m thinking a Tablet PC is the way forward, but it’ll take something more to beat paper.
∞ Frank Bisono said 1721 days ago:
Have you tried looking at StickyBrain? StickyBrain allows me to sync across Mac’s with it’s .Mac support, and I can also sync it to my Palm based Treo 650. Kind of the best of both worlds and very flexible!!!∞ Jason said 1721 days ago:
I just use Stickies for all my notes. I don’t need all the extra stuff that Backpack and Ta-Da lists have.∞ Laura said 1721 days ago:
I would recommend Backpack (backpackit.com) highly. The free version allows five pages (plus your home page), so you could have GTDesque lists (@Action, @Reference, etc.), or Work, Home, Projects, Grocery Shopping, etc. One thing I love is that a task you’ve checked off goes to the bottom of the list and is displayed in a tiny font, greyed out, but to add it back to the active list, you just uncheck it. This is perfect for a list of recurring tasks, such as housework (ugh). In addition to lists, you can have text notes. I’m really loving this tool. As someone else mentioned, the ability to email to any of the pages is a real bonus. I have BackPack set as one of the tabs that opens with Firefox (along with Yahoo, Newsgator, Typepad, del.icio.us, and Mark Taw’s elegant Get Back to Work page.∞ Christoph Freitag said 1720 days ago:
Try using Leo which is a cross platform outliner and text editor. I use it under Windows, Linux and on the Mac, keep all my notes in a single XML file on my iPod and access them whereever I am through Leo. If it isn’t installed on a particular computer I can even view/edit my notes with a simple text editor. By the way: my favourite one is Vim which is also a cross platform open-source programme.∞ This Song said 1719 days ago:
Why does my comments not allow textile formatting? And yours does?∞ oneighturbo said 1719 days ago:
great stuff everyone. ive been trying to get used to Ta-da and Backpack.I’ll pipe in with konfabulator. Leaves a little widget on the deskie wth my list.
My best option right now is Sunbird but Im having trouble with Backpack syncing with it.
∞ Sam said 1719 days ago:
_“I can view these lists individually, as well as all together on one page.”_Thats great – I never really thought of checking all my to-dos lists because I’m always using Basecamp in “project” mode.
But thats so important! Having 3 or 5 or 10 to-do lists never made much sense to me. I’m one person, I need to see what needs to get done, and then do it! (after my morning coffee and news browsing, etc, ad infinitum)
∞ Kat said 1718 days ago:
Another very nice tool for keeping track of projects and to-dos is Tasktoy. It’s very simple and clear, but also allows one to categorize tasks by context or project and to attach notes. I’m liking it a lot.∞ Mark said 1717 days ago:
I use a combination of Burnout menu, iCal and then when working on projects etc I use Omni outliner a lot to list and check off things as they are done.∞ Steven Woods said 1717 days ago:
Text file on desktop – simple, functional and easy to sync (copy / paste) ... anything else just seems like a waste of time- i’d rather spend my time completing the tasks, rather than making sure they’re organised with colours/etc .. procrastination at its best!∞ James Greig said 1716 days ago:
There is NO WAY you can beat a pen and pencil for a to-do-list – nothing else gives you the same satisfaction when it comes to scribbling out that nagging task you’ve been putting off for 6 months and finally got round to!!!!!!∞ Steven Woods said 1716 days ago:
Thats very true … I don’t know, I just don’t get the same satisfaction from clicking a checkbox, to actually scrunching a post-it note and lobbing it into a bin… especially one with a mini basketball net ;)∞ Paul Nishikawa said 1715 days ago:
Hey Jon,You’ve re-inspired me to get back to GTD. And I already had a basecamp account for my business. Just looking at what you’ve suggested, and I was wondering if you have any other examples of Message Categories you’re using besides “code snippets”?
∞ neuro said 1715 days ago:
I found a combo of Basecamp, Outlook 2003, a Dell Axim X5 and Plaxo works really well. That plus Workrave to get me off the keyboard once in a while :)∞ Picturesell said 1714 days ago:
I love great tools. When you find them you don’t know anymore how you could live without them.Wouldn’t it be nice if we could have more of tools like that. I’m thinking now may be being active in search of what tools you need may help there.
Check my article about new tools for webdesign at http://picturesell.blogspot.com/
May be together we can do something about it.
∞ timfm said 1712 days ago:
61 comments and no one mentioned bsag’s Tracks ? Requires Ruby on Rails and is still in early development, but v1.03 (with Ajax) is due out sometime soon. I’ve been using it for a while and love it. It’s designed specifically for GTD, and the developer is tres smart.∞ Martin said 1710 days ago:
I’m surprised only one person has even mentioned OneNote…Now I know that most web geeks are Mac users (and that you like doing things web-based) but you really are missing out on what is probably the best solution out there
Super-feature-richness may be a bad thing for some people, but the intuitiveness that OneNote offers is (in my experience at least) unrivalled. Combine that with the kind of integration that will never be possible in an open source environment, and über-powerful (not too mention smile-inducing) new shared sessions capabilities and you end up with a very slick and effective way of doing things.
Check it out, it kicks ass.
∞ Jon Hicks said 1710 days ago:
Hmmmm….“OneNote – Operating system: Windows XP or later…’
Thats maybe why I haven’t tried it then! I also don’t give an arse about integration with MS Office. Nothing against it – I just don’t use it!
∞ Martin said 1710 days ago:
Hehe…Which is what I meant with “you’re missing out” :-) I honestly don’t think that there’s a more powerful way to organise things than using the Office System – and with that I mean the integrated whole, the “thing” Microsoft calls a productivity suite (not just the disjointed parts that everybody loves to hate :-).
My point really? The tools don’t matter, the outcome does. Doing things the way I’m talking about is so seamless that you tend to not think about it… All the difference in the world.
∞ Jon Hicks said 1710 days ago:
I certainly don’t hate Ms Office, I just don’t need it. The integration and seamlessness you mention is how I feel using Mac OS X.∞ pickupjojo said 1710 days ago:
Hey, nice design, congratulations !Very sweety and beautiful… :-)